MIL-002 · Use of military power · Strikes
Military strikes on boats in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific: war-powers votes, watchdog review and the legal memo
Stage 4 of 5: Legal action · Lawsuits, subpoenas, charges · Last development 30 Sep 2026
Since September 2025 the U.S. military has struck boats in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific that the administration says belong to drug cartels it has designated as terrorist organizations; it told Congress the U.S. is in a "non-international armed conflict" with them. The Senate rejected two war-powers resolutions on the strikes, 48-51 and 49-51. In May 2026 the Defense Department inspector general opened a review of whether the military followed its targeting procedures. In a Freedom of Information Act suit, Judge Paul Engelmayer ruled on 30 September 2026 that most of the government's grounds for withholding the Justice Department legal memo on the strikes fail and ordered it handed to the court for private review.
The legal memo has not been made public and the court has not decided whether it must be released. The inspector general's review covers targeting procedures, not legality, and has published no findings. The families' lawsuit in Massachusetts has not been decided. Strike and death figures are given as each source reported them at the time and are not added up here. People killed in the strikes are not named. Being listed is not a finding of wrongdoing.
- People
- Donald Trump, Pete Hegseth, Marco Rubio, Tim Kaine, Adam Schiff, Rand Paul, Paul Engelmayer
- Reviewed by
- U.S. Senate, DoD Inspector General, Federal court (S.D.N.Y.), Federal court (Massachusetts)
Follow this case
See the cases you follow, and which have news, on Following. Or get each update in a feed reader or by email: feed for this case (how).
Timeline
Judge Paul Engelmayer, in a 66-page ruling, rejects the deliberative-process and attorney-client privilege grounds, orders the memo handed to the court for private review within 14 days and an account of everyone who has seen it, and leaves the presidential communications privilege open. "The fact that a military commander has a 'need to know' the legal parameters of his authority does not make him a presidential adviser." [8]
The judge finds the Pentagon has treated the memo as its "working law": "The Memo binds DOD and defines the parameters of its authority to undertake boat strikes." He calls it "all but certain" that parts of the legal analysis fall outside the classified-information exemptions. [9]
Article V of Rep. Massie's articles of impeachment against Hegseth charges (allegation) lethal targeting of suspected drug traffickers in place of maritime law enforcement, causing "at least 221 deaths". See MIL-005. [10]
The court hears arguments. According to the plaintiffs, the government invokes the presidential communications privilege and its lawyer acknowledges that parts of the memo's legal analysis could be released without revealing classified information. [7]
The Defense Department inspector general confirms a self-initiated evaluation of whether the military followed the six-phase Joint Targeting Cycle in the strikes; it will not examine whether the strikes were legal. AP reports the strikes have killed at least 193 people since early September. [6]
Families of two Trinidadian men killed in a strike on 14 October 2025 sue the United States in federal court in Massachusetts under the Death on the High Seas Act and the Alien Tort Statute. They say (allegation) the U.S. "is not engaged in an armed conflict, as the government has implausibly claimed." [5]
The ACLU, NYCLU and Center for Constitutional Rights sue in federal court in Manhattan for the legal opinion. [4]
The Senate rejects the motion to discharge S.J.Res. 90 (removal of U.S. forces from hostilities within or against Venezuela), 49-51; Sens. Murkowski and Paul vote yes. [2]
The ACLU and the Center for Constitutional Rights file a Freedom of Information Act request for the Justice Department Office of Legal Counsel opinion on the strikes. [4]
The Senate rejects a war-powers resolution by Sens. Schiff and Kaine on the boat strikes, 48-51; Republicans Paul and Murkowski vote yes, Democrat Fetterman votes no. The administration had notified Congress that the U.S. is in a "non-international armed conflict" with cartels it designated as terrorist organizations. [1]
Responses
- Secretary of State Marco Rubio: "These are targeted strikes against imminent threats against the United States." [1]
- White House: Relies on "the president's authority under Article II of the Constitution as Commander-in-Chief" for the strikes. [3]
- Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth: "These narco-terrorists have killed more Americans than al-Qaeda, and they will be treated the same." [3]
- Justice Department and Pentagon (FOIA case): Argued the memo is privileged; the administration has said the legal justification cannot be released because of national security implications. [8]
- Sen. Mike Crapo (R-Idaho): "These strikes were fully compliant and fully justified." [1]
- Sen. Tim Kaine (D-Va.): "We should not be going to war without a vote of Congress." [3]
- Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.): "To kill indiscriminately is akin to summary execution." [3]
- Sen. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.): "I feel it is plainly unconstitutional." [1]
- Jeffrey Stein, ACLU (plaintiff's lawyer): Called the 30 September order "a huge step in the right direction". [8]
Sources
- CBS News, 8 Oct 2025 (archived copy)
- Senate Periodical Press Gallery floor log, 6 Nov 2025
- Washington Times, 6 Nov 2025 (archived copy)
- ACLU (plaintiff), FOIA case page (archived copy)
- ACLU (plaintiffs' counsel), press release, 27 Jan 2026 (archived copy)
- PBS NewsHour (AP), 20 May 2026 (archived copy)
- ACLU (plaintiff), press release, 24 Jun 2026 (archived copy)
- ABC News, 30 Sep 2026 (archived copy)
- The Washington Sun, 30 Sep 2026 (archived copy)
- Rep. Thomas Massie, press release, 15 Sep 2026 (archived copy)
Cite this case
Public Trust Tracker. "Military strikes on boats in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific: war-powers votes, watchdog review and the legal memo" (MIL-002). Last updated 30 Sep 2026. https://publictrusttracker.org/case/mil-002-military-strikes-on-boats-in-the-caribbean-and-eastern/
Suggest a fact check