Public Trust Tracker Search

PWR-005 · Use of power · Investigation

Six Democratic lawmakers' "illegal orders" video and the Pentagon action against Sen. Kelly

Stage 4 of 5: Legal action · Lawsuits, subpoenas, charges · Last development 27 Oct 2026

In November 2025 six Democratic members of Congress, all military or intelligence veterans, released a video telling service members they can refuse illegal orders. Trump called it "SEDITIOUS BEHAVIOR, punishable by DEATH!" In January 2026 Defense Secretary Hegseth censured Sen. Mark Kelly, a retired Navy captain, and opened a review of his retirement rank. In February a grand jury in Washington reportedly declined to indict the lawmakers. A judge blocked the Pentagon action against Kelly as a likely First Amendment violation; the government's appeal is pending. In September 2026 Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.) included the action against Kelly in articles of impeachment against Hegseth; the House has not voted on them.

The grand jury result comes from unnamed sources; the Justice Department has not commented on it. The appeals court has not ruled.

People
Mark Kelly, Elissa Slotkin, Jason Crow, Chrissy Houlahan, Maggie Goodlander, Chris Deluzio, Pete Hegseth, Jeanine Pirro
Reviewed by
Federal court (D.D.C.), D.C. Circuit

Timeline

  1. The appeal is still awaiting a ruling. [8]

  2. Speaker Mike Johnson sends the House home for the election recess before a vote; he calls the resolution "a publicity stunt by someone who wants attention" and says it "will immediately be tabled" when members return. [10]

  3. Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.) files privileged articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Hegseth. Article VI alleges that Defense Department authority was used to retaliate against Sen. Kelly for speech questioning unlawful military orders (allegation). [9]

  4. The D.C. Circuit hears the appeal. [6]

  5. The government appeals to the D.C. Circuit. [4]

  6. Judge Richard Leon blocks the censure and the rank review: the defendants "have trampled on Senator Kelly's First Amendment freedoms". [2]

  7. A grand jury in Washington declines to indict the lawmakers, according to unnamed sources; U.S. Attorney Pirro's office had investigated. [1]

  8. Kelly sues Hegseth in federal court in Washington. [4]

  9. Hegseth issues a letter of censure to Kelly and starts proceedings on his retirement rank. [3]

  10. Trump posts that the video is "SEDITIOUS BEHAVIOR, punishable by DEATH!" [2]

  11. Sens. Kelly and Slotkin and Reps. Crow, Houlahan, Goodlander and Deluzio release the video. [1]

Responses

  • Defense Secretary Hegseth: Called Kelly's statements "seditious" when announcing the review. [2]
  • Defense Department spokesperson: Does not comment on ongoing litigation. [7]
  • Sen. Elissa Slotkin: Called the inquiry a "politicized investigation". [5]
  • Sen. Mark Kelly: Says the Pentagon action is an effort to silence dissent. [1]
  • Speaker Mike Johnson: Called Massie's impeachment resolution "a publicity stunt by someone who wants attention". [10]

Sources

  1. Scripps News, Feb 2026
  2. GPB (NPR), 12 Feb 2026
  3. States United Democracy Center (advocacy group), Kelly v. Hegseth
  4. Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse, Kelly v. Hegseth
  5. JURIST, Feb 2026
  6. Penn CERL (academic centre, amicus for Kelly), May 2026
  7. Axios Phoenix, 12 Jan 2026
  8. KTAR, 27 Oct 2026
  9. Rep. Thomas Massie, press release, 15 Sep 2026 (archived copy)
  10. WSET (Sinclair), 16 Sep 2026 (archived copy)

Cite this case

Public Trust Tracker. "Six Democratic lawmakers' "illegal orders" video and the Pentagon action against Sen. Kelly" (PWR-005). Last updated 27 Oct 2026. https://publictrusttracker.org/case/pwr-005-six-democratic-lawmakers-illegal-orders-video-and-the/

Suggest a fact check