PWR-011 · Use of power · Records
Justice Department opinion calls the Presidential Records Act unconstitutional
Stage 4 of 5: Legal action · Lawsuits, subpoenas, charges · Last development 28 Oct 2026
On 1 April 2026 the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel concluded that the Presidential Records Act, the 1978 law that requires the White House to preserve its records for the public, is unconstitutional and that the President "need not further comply". The American Historical Association and American Oversight sued. On 20 May 2026 Judge John Bates ordered the White House Office, the National Security Council, DOGE and presidential advisers to comply, including preserving records. The government filed a notice of compliance and appealed; the appeal was argued on 16 October 2026.
Preliminary order; the appeals court has not ruled. American Oversight is a plaintiff.
- People
- Donald Trump
- Reviewed by
- Federal court (D.D.C.), D.C. Circuit
Follow this case
See the cases you follow, and which have news, on Following. Or get each update in a feed reader or by email: feed for this case (how).
Timeline
House Judiciary and Oversight ranking members Raskin and Garcia write to President Trump asking him to preserve his conversations with AI chatbots, after reports he consulted Grok before the Venezuela operation, and to brief them on how AI prompts and responses are kept as presidential records. Minority letter; no deadline stated. [6]
Reps. Jamie Raskin and Robert Garcia ask Trump to preserve the prompts and outputs of AI chatbots (Grok, ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity) used in official duties, which they say "are the sole property of the United States and legally must be preserved", and request a briefing by 11 November. [7]
The D.C. Circuit hears the appeal. [5]
The government appeals to the D.C. Circuit. [3]
The government files a notice of compliance. [3]
Judge Bates orders the White House Office, NSC, DOGE and presidential advisers to comply with the law, including preserving records and keeping official copies of disappearing messages. [4]
The American Historical Association and American Oversight sue in federal court in Washington. [2]
The Office of Legal Counsel issues "Constitutionality of the Presidential Records Act", finding the law unconstitutional. [1]
Responses
- Office of Legal Counsel: The Act "exceeds any preservation power because Congress cannot preserve presidential records merely for the sake of posterity." [2]
- White House: "President Trump is committed to preserving records from his historic Administration." [2]
- White House official: "The White House preserves all required records in accordance with the law." [8]
Sources
- Office of Legal Counsel opinion, 1 Apr 2026
- KFGO (Reuters), Apr 2026
- Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse, AHA v. Trump
- DRG News, 21 May 2026
- New York Almanack, Oct 2026
- House Judiciary Democrats press release and letter, 28-29 Oct 2026
- Reps. Raskin and Garcia, letter to President Trump, 28 Oct 2026 (PDF)
- Nextgov, Oct 2026
Cite this case
Public Trust Tracker. "Justice Department opinion calls the Presidential Records Act unconstitutional" (PWR-011). Last updated 28 Oct 2026. https://publictrusttracker.org/case/pwr-011-justice-department-opinion-calls-the-presidential-records/
Suggest a fact check