PWR-017 · Use of power · Court orders
Alien Enemies Act removals to El Salvador's CECOT prison and the court orders
Stage 4 of 5: Legal action · Lawsuits, subpoenas, charges · Last development 29 Sep 2026
In March 2025 President Trump invoked the Alien Enemies Act against alleged members of the Tren de Aragua gang. On 15 March, after Judge James Boasberg ordered a halt to removals under the proclamation, two flights carried Venezuelan men to El Salvador's CECOT prison. The U.S. agreed to pay El Salvador to hold them. Boasberg found probable cause of criminal contempt; the inquiry has since been stopped and restarted on appeal. In July 2025 the men were sent to Venezuela in a prisoner exchange. The full D.C. Circuit heard argument on the contempt inquiry on 29 September 2026; no ruling had been reported as of 8 November 2026.
The administration denies violating any court order. According to her declaration (Washington Post), then-Homeland Security Secretary Noem decided to proceed with the transfers; government filings say she acted on legal advice (Newsweek). The probable-cause finding was vacated on appeal in August 2025. No official has been charged with contempt, and the full appeals court had not ruled as of 8 November 2026. Court opinions are described here through news reports except the Supreme Court documents and the Proclamation. Being listed is not a finding of wrongdoing.
- People
- Donald Trump, Kristi Noem, Marco Rubio, Pam Bondi, Todd Blanche
- Reviewed by
- U.S. District Court for D.C. (Chief Judge Boasberg), D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, Supreme Court
Follow this case
See the cases you follow, and which have news, on Following. Or get each update in a feed reader or by email: feed for this case (how).
Timeline
The full D.C. Circuit hears arguments on whether Boasberg may continue the contempt inquiry. Government filings say then-Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem acted on legal advice. No ruling had been reported as of 8 November 2026. [13]
The full D.C. Circuit agrees to rehear the case and vacates the April panel decision. [12]
A divided D.C. Circuit panel (Judges Rao and Walker; Judge Childs dissenting) halts Boasberg's renewed contempt inquiry, calling it "a clear abuse of discretion". [11]
Boasberg orders the government to provide boarding letters and pay air travel for men now in third countries who want to return for their proceedings. He does not order returns from Venezuela, citing foreign-affairs concerns. [9]
Boasberg rules that the class of men removed on 15 March was "denied their due-process rights" and that the U.S. kept custody of them in El Salvador. He orders the government to facilitate hearings, either by bringing the men back or by allowing remedies from abroad. [8]
A D.C. Circuit panel (Judges Katsas and Rao; Judge Pillard dissenting) vacates Boasberg's probable-cause finding of criminal contempt. [7]
The Venezuelan men held at CECOT are sent to Venezuela in an exchange in which 10 Americans are released, as announced by President Bukele and Secretary of State Rubio. [6]
Boasberg finds that the government's actions "demonstrate a willful disregard" of his order, "sufficient for the Court to conclude that probable cause exists to find the Government in criminal contempt". He gives it a choice: explain the steps it will take to comply, or name the officials who decided not to halt the transfers. [2]
Thomson Reuters Foundation's Context reports that under a deal between Presidents Bukele and Trump, the United States is paying El Salvador $6 million to hold the Venezuelan deportees. [5]
In a separate case (Noem v. Abrego Garcia), the Supreme Court says the lower court order "properly requires the Government to 'facilitate'" the release from CECOT of a Salvadoran man whose 15 March removal the government acknowledged violated a withholding order; it called the removal an "administrative error". [4]
The Supreme Court (Trump v. J.G.G.) vacates Boasberg's temporary restraining orders. It rules that challenges must be brought in habeas in the district of confinement, and that detainees must get notice allowing them to seek habeas relief before removal. [3]
Judge Boasberg orders, orally and then in writing, a halt to removals under the proclamation. Two flights leave Harlingen, Texas, at about 5:25 and 5:45 p.m., and their passengers are transferred into the Salvadoran prison early the next morning, according to his later opinion. [2]
Proclamation 10903 declares Venezuelan citizens aged 14 or older who are members of Tren de Aragua, and are not naturalized or lawful permanent residents, liable to be "apprehended, restrained, secured, and removed as Alien Enemies". [1]
Responses
- White House: Spokeswoman Abigail Jackson called the 22 Dec 2025 ruling "an order that has no basis in law and undermines national security" and said the administration would appeal (NPR). [8]
- Department of Homeland Security: Spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin said the men were "removed under the proper legal authorities" (NPR, Feb 2026). [10]
- Justice Department: Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche said the April 2026 panel ruling "should finally end" Boasberg's campaign against Department attorneys (CBS). [11]
- Justice Department: In the en banc argument, DOJ lawyers said there was no violation of the orders and called the inquiry an "intrusive and rapidly metastasizing criminal investigation" (Washington Post). [14]
- Secretary of State Marco Rubio: Said the payment arrangement would hold accused gang members in "very good jails at a fair price that will also save our taxpayer dollars" (Context, Apr 2025). [5]
- ACLU (counsel for the class): Called the April 2026 panel decision a "blow to the rule of law" (CBS). [11]
Sources
- Proclamation 10903, 90 FR 13033, 20 Mar 2025 (govinfo)
- Roll Call, 16 Apr 2025
- Supreme Court, Trump v. J.G.G., No. 24A931, 7 Apr 2025 (PDF)
- Supreme Court, Noem v. Abrego Garcia, No. 24A949, 10 Apr 2025 (PDF)
- Context (Thomson Reuters Foundation), Apr 2025
- WUSF (NPR), 18 Jul 2025
- PBS NewsHour (AP), 8 Aug 2025
- KPBS (NPR), 22 Dec 2025
- ABC30 (ABC News), 12 Feb 2026
- NPR, 12 Feb 2026
- CBS News, 14 Apr 2026
- Bloomberg Law, 22 Jun 2026
- Newsweek, 29 Sep 2026
- The Daily Record (Washington Post), 30 Sep 2026
Cite this case
Public Trust Tracker. "Alien Enemies Act removals to El Salvador's CECOT prison and the court orders" (PWR-017). Last updated 29 Sep 2026. https://publictrusttracker.org/case/pwr-017-alien-enemies-act-removals-to-el-salvadors-cecot-prison-and/
Suggest a fact check