Public Trust Tracker Search

PWR-002 · Use of power · Prosecution

Three criminal cases against former FBI Director James Comey

Stage 4 of 5: Legal action · Lawsuits, subpoenas, charges · Last development 30 Oct 2026

The Justice Department has brought three criminal cases against James Comey, the FBI director Trump fired in 2017. The first, over his 2020 testimony to Congress, was dismissed in November 2025 because the prosecutor who brought it had been unlawfully appointed; the government's appeal is pending. The second, filed in North Carolina in April 2026, charges him with threatening the President over an Instagram photo of seashells spelling "86 47". The third, over an alleged 2016 disclosure to a reporter, was unsealed in Washington on 26 October 2026. Comey denies the charges and calls the cases vindictive.

No case has reached a verdict. The claim of vindictive prosecution is Comey's and is before the courts.

People
James Comey, Lindsey Halligan, Pam Bondi, Todd Blanche, Kash Patel
Reviewed by
Federal court (E.D. Va.), Federal court (E.D.N.C.), Federal court (D.D.C.), 4th Circuit

Timeline

  1. Judge Trevor McFadden hears Comey's motion to dismiss the D.C. case as time-barred. The prosecutor says the department filed the charge to "toll the statute of limitations" while a grand jury continues ("We had a clock problem"). No ruling. [9]

  2. Judge McFadden postpones ruling on the time-bar motion so prosecutors can seek an indictment from a grand jury that is hearing evidence. He says he would be "extremely frustrated if there's some sort of dawn raid"; the prosecutor: "That's not going to happen." [10]

  3. Judge Trevor McFadden unseals the third case; Comey moves to dismiss it as too late under the statute of limitations. [8]

  4. The Justice Department files a third case in Washington, D.C., over an alleged 2016 disclosure to a New York Times reporter. [7]

  5. The North Carolina court moves the arraignment to January 2027 at Comey's request; his motions to dismiss, including for vindictive prosecution, are pending. [6]

  6. The 4th Circuit hears the government's appeal; two of three judges appear skeptical of its position. [5]

  7. A grand jury in North Carolina indicts Comey on two threat counts over a May 2025 Instagram photo of seashells reading "86 47". [4]

  8. The Justice Department appeals the dismissal to the 4th Circuit. [3]

  9. Judge Cameron Currie dismisses the indictment: interim U.S. Attorney Lindsey Halligan was unlawfully appointed. [2]

  10. A grand jury in Alexandria, Virginia indicts Comey on two counts (false statement to Congress, obstruction) over his 2020 testimony. [1]

Responses

  • Attorney General Bondi, 25 Sep 2025: "No one is above the law… We will follow the facts in this case." [1]
  • Acting Attorney General Blanche, 28 Apr 2026: Said the seashell post is conduct "we will always investigate and regularly prosecute". [4]
  • U.S. Attorney Ellis Boyle (E.D.N.C.), affidavit: No one directed or pressured his office to seek the indictment. [6]
  • Justice Department spokesperson, Oct 2026: The third case was filed to stop the statute of limitations running out, a "widely recognized practice in federal court." [8]
  • James Comey: Calls the third case an "appalling abuse of the Department of Justice" and says he is "still innocent". [7]
  • Comey lawyer Ephraim McDowell (30 Oct 2026 hearing): The charge is "time barred and must be dismissed." [9]

Sources

  1. Justice Department release, 25 Sep 2025
  2. Lawfare, Nov 2025
  3. States United Democracy Center (advocacy group), appeal tracker
  4. Fox 9, 28 Apr 2026
  5. Missouri Lawyers Media, 16 Sep 2026
  6. Carolina Journal, Sep 2026
  7. NPR Illinois (NPR), 26 Oct 2026
  8. Missouri Lawyers Media (Washington Post), 27 Oct 2026
  9. The Hill via Yahoo News, 30 Oct 2026
  10. AP via Dayton Daily News, 30 Oct 2026

Cite this case

Public Trust Tracker. "Three criminal cases against former FBI Director James Comey" (PWR-002). Last updated 30 Oct 2026. https://publictrusttracker.org/case/pwr-002-three-criminal-cases-against-former-fbi-director-james-comey/

Suggest a fact check