Public Trust Tracker Search

PWR-003 · Use of power · Prosecution

Prosecution of New York Attorney General Letitia James

Stage 4 of 5: Legal action · Lawsuits, subpoenas, charges · Last development 15 Sep 2026

Letitia James, New York's attorney general, who brought the state's civil fraud case against Trump and his company, was indicted on bank-fraud charges in October 2025 after FHFA Director Bill Pulte referred her mortgage applications to the Justice Department. The case was dismissed in November 2025 because the prosecutor had been unlawfully appointed, and grand juries declined to indict her again in December 2025. The government's appeal of the dismissal is pending. Pulte sent new referrals in March 2026, with no reported action. Related case: INV-039.

The December 2025 grand jury refusals were reported from unnamed sources. No charges are pending.

People
Letitia James, Bill Pulte, Lindsey Halligan
Reviewed by
Federal court (E.D. Va.), 4th Circuit, 2nd Circuit

Timeline

  1. The 4th Circuit hears the government's appeal together with the Comey case. [8]

  2. The 2nd Circuit, 2-1, upholds a ruling that a separate set of subpoenas to James's office was void because acting U.S. Attorney John Sarcone was not lawfully serving. [7]

  3. Pulte sends new criminal referrals to prosecutors in Illinois and Florida over insurance applications on two properties. [6]

  4. The Justice Department appeals the dismissal to the 4th Circuit. [5]

  5. A second grand jury declines to indict James again, after one in Norfolk the week before, according to unnamed sources. [4]

  6. Judge Currie dismisses the case: the prosecutor, Lindsey Halligan, was unlawfully appointed. [3]

  7. A grand jury in Virginia indicts James on bank fraud and false statements to a financial institution. [2]

  8. FHFA Director Pulte refers James to the Justice Department, alleging misrepresentations on mortgage applications. [1]

Responses

  • FHFA Director Pulte (referral letter): The records raise "serious concerns about the validity of Ms. James' representations on mortgage applications." [1]
  • U.S. Attorney Halligan, 9 Oct 2025: "The charges as alleged in this case represent intentional, criminal acts and tremendous breaches of the public's trust." [2]
  • Spokesperson for Letitia James: Calls it weaponization of government: "She will not be intimidated by bullies." [1]
  • Abbe Lowell, lawyer for James: The grand jury refusals show the case "should never have seen the light of day." [4]

Sources

  1. Fox 7 Austin, 2025
  2. Justice Department (E.D. Va.) release, 9 Oct 2025
  3. Lawfare, Nov 2025
  4. 6abc (ABC News), Dec 2025
  5. States United Democracy Center (advocacy group), appeal tracker
  6. Washington Examiner, Mar 2026
  7. Spectrum News, 21 Aug 2026
  8. Missouri Lawyers Media, 16 Sep 2026

Cite this case

Public Trust Tracker. "Prosecution of New York Attorney General Letitia James" (PWR-003). Last updated 15 Sep 2026. https://publictrusttracker.org/case/pwr-003-prosecution-of-new-york-attorney-general-letitia-james/

Suggest a fact check