PWR-020 · Use of power · Prosecution
Broadview Six: judge orders U.S. Attorney Boutros to testify about the protesters' prosecution
Stage 4 of 5: Legal action · Lawsuits, subpoenas, charges · Last development 16 Nov 2026
Federal prosecutors in Chicago, led by U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros, charged six people who protested outside the Broadview ICE facility; the case collapsed in May 2026. The defendants asked Judge April Perry to examine the prosecutors' conduct. She appointed a law professor as amicus on whether she can appoint a special prosecutor, and on 2 November ordered Boutros and three other prosecutors to testify under oath on 16 November about grand jury transcripts, their redactions and the accuracy of statements to the court.
No special prosecutor has been appointed and no finding of misconduct has been made; the amicus report is due in December. The defendants are private individuals and are not named here. Being listed is not a finding of wrongdoing.
- People
- Andrew Boutros, April Perry, Stanley Woodward
- Reviewed by
- Federal court (N.D. Ill.)
Follow this case
See the cases you follow, and which have news, on Following. Or get each update in a feed reader or by email: feed for this case (how).
Timeline
At a status hearing attended by Woodward, Judge Perry keeps the 2 December hearing at which Boutros and three assistant U.S. attorneys are to testify: "I don't intend to ask any questions that will call for a privileged answer." She orders written accounts of any potentially privileged testimony by Friday 20 November, sent to her rather than the public docket; the government may respond by 25 November. Lawyers for the three assistant U.S. attorneys say their clients do not plan to invoke the Fifth Amendment. [11]
In a late-Sunday filing, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward says U.S. Attorney Boutros and the three other prosecutors ordered to testify "have all been instructed to assert those privileges", argues that cross-examining them would carry an "intolerably high risk" of breaching them, and raises seeking relief from the 7th Circuit. [12]
The Justice Department submits a revised privilege log by the 12 November deadline. Judge Perry postpones the hearing at which U.S. Attorney Boutros and other prosecutors were to testify from 16 November to 2 December, at the request of the witnesses' attorneys and "with the consent" of the Justice Department; 16 November becomes a status hearing. [10]
Judge Perry declines to call off the 16 November hearing, writing that she has inherent authority to hold a hearing on factual matters and that "The Government does not represent at least 3/4 of the individuals who have been asked to testify." [9]
Judge Perry calls the Justice Department's privilege log "noncompliant" and says its production of two emails without metadata "sheds no light on the only relevant issue"; she orders a revised production by 12 November. [9]
Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward files a response asking the judge to clarify her authority and the hearing's purpose, raising the possibility that the prosecutors could invoke the Fifth Amendment: "The court has presented the United States Attorney and his subordinates with a Catch-22"; "No authority exists for a federal judge to hold a mini-trial". He suggests the hearing be called off so the Department can run its own internal investigation. [8]
In response to Judge Perry's records order, the Justice Department files a memo from Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward saying its communications about charging decisions are privileged, and produces one item: a 14 Oct 2025 email to U.S. Attorney Boutros attaching a grand jury transcript. The Chicago Tribune reports the memo was filed more than an hour after the 2 p.m. deadline. Woodward writes that privileges should not "suddenly disappear" when a judge opens an inquiry, which "would seriously undermine the separation of powers." No ruling on moving the 16 Nov hearing has been reported. [7]
Judge Perry sets the rules for the 16 November hearing: "No cross-examination by other witnesses or their attorneys will be permitted"; each witness will be asked about matters within their personal knowledge. No ruling on Assistant U.S. Attorney Hogan's request to move the hearing has been reported. The Justice Department declined to comment. [6]
Assistant U.S. Attorney William Hogan, one of the prosecutors ordered to testify, asks through his own lawyer to move the hearing from 16 to 23 November, writing that the government's interests and some witnesses' testimony "may not be aligned" with his. No ruling on the request yet. [3]
Judge Perry gives the Justice Department until 2 p.m. on Monday, 9 November, to produce the records she requested about its outside communications. [4]
In a seven-page order, Perry directs Boutros and three other prosecutors to "testify under oath" at a 16 November hearing; she calls Boutros's denial "hard to credit". [1]
(Allegation) Douglas DePodesta, former head of the FBI's Chicago office, sues U.S. Attorney Boutros, FBI Director Patel, Attorney General Blanche, the FBI and the Justice Department in a nine-count suit (Judge Matthew Kennelly). He says he was forced out after Boutros falsely told superiors in Washington that he "conspired to destroy the Broadview Six case." Boutros did not comment; the Justice Department did not respond. [5]
Judge Perry names University of Chicago law professor William Baude as amicus to advise on her authority to appoint a special prosecutor; his report is due in December. [1]
The prosecution of the six protesters ends after charges are reduced and then dropped. [1]
Responses
- Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward: Said the United States "has not agreed to provide any information" the judge sought. [2]
Sources
- Chicago Sun-Times, 2 Nov 2026
- WBEZ, 2 Nov 2026
- Chicago Sun-Times, 5 Nov 2026
- Raw Story, 5 Nov 2026
- Chicago Sun-Times, 2 Nov 2026
- Chicago Sun-Times, 6 Nov 2026
- Chicago Tribune via Yahoo News, 9 Nov 2026
- Chicago Sun-Times, 10 Nov 2026
- Chicago Tribune via Yahoo News, 11 Nov 2026
- Chicago Tribune via Yahoo News, 12 Nov 2026
- Chicago Sun-Times, 16 Nov 2026
- Chicago Tribune via Yahoo News, 16 Nov 2026
Cite this case
Public Trust Tracker. "Broadview Six: judge orders U.S. Attorney Boutros to testify about the protesters' prosecution" (PWR-020). Last updated 16 Nov 2026. https://publictrusttracker.org/case/pwr-020-broadview-six-judge-orders-u-s-attorney-boutros-to-testify/
Suggest a fact check