Public Trust Tracker Search

PWR-021 · Use of power · Court orders

Court orders on the Attorney General's compliance with the Epstein Files Transparency Act (Phang v. Blanche)

Stage 4 of 5: Legal action · Lawsuits, subpoenas, charges · Last development 9 Nov 2026

Journalist Katie Phang sued Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche under the Administrative Procedure Act over the Justice Department's release of records under the Epstein Files Transparency Act, which set a 19 December 2025 deadline for the documents and a redaction log. On 25 June 2026 Judge Emmet G. Sullivan granted a preliminary injunction, writing that "The Attorney General conceded that he is in violation of the Act." The D.C. Circuit denied the Department a stay pending appeal on 28 October 2026. On 9 November 2026 the court ordered FBI interview notes published within fourteen days, unless the Department seeks a stay from the D.C. Circuit.

The appeals (Nos. 26-5299 and 26-5334) are pending, and the 9 November publication order is paused if the Department asks the D.C. Circuit for a stay. The court's finding that the Attorney General conceded the merits rests on the Department not answering the merits arguments, not on a ruling after full argument. This case covers the Department's handling of the law only. Being listed is not a finding of wrongdoing.

People
Todd Blanche, Emmet G. Sullivan
Reviewed by
Federal court (D.D.C.), U.S. Court of Appeals (D.C. Cir.)

Timeline

  1. The court orders the Attorney General to publish in the Epstein Library within fourteen days the FBI interview notes behind three FD-302 reports, with redactions under the Act. It writes: "The Court will not stay its order but rather will establish a deadline that gives Defendant adequate time—fourteen days—to appeal and request a stay". [3]

  2. The court denies the Department's motion to postpone the administrative record, writing that the cited documents do not explain why the 15 February 2026 report to Congress meets the redaction-log requirement, "Nor do the documents provide an explanation for the six-month time lag" before its Federal Register publication. The record list is due 17 November. [4]

  3. The court notes that the Department "has begun its review of the foreign language documents" and orders a sworn status report by 10 December. [5]

  4. The D.C. Circuit, in a per curiam order, denies the Department's motion for a stay pending appeal of the 25 June and 16 September orders (Nos. 26-5299, 26-5334). [5]

  5. The court issues a further memorandum opinion and order (ECF 43); the Department's motion for a partial stay is later denied. [5]

  6. Judge Sullivan grants a preliminary injunction. By 2 July the Attorney General must release, or "show cause" for withholding, unredacted sender and recipient names in eight emails, "potential co-conspirator names" in two DOJ documents and the "underlying FBI interview notes"; begin reviewing foreign-language materials; and publish the redaction log in the Federal Register. [1]

  7. In the opinion, the court writes that the Attorney General "does not respond substantively" to the merits arguments and so "has conceded" them, and that "The Attorney General conceded that he is in violation of the Act." It refuses his request for a seven-day or sixty-day stay. [2]

Responses

  • Justice Department (court filings): Argued that the Act "supplements FOIA ... it does not supplant FOIA or create a parallel enforcement framework", and that the public interest is "not served by compelling the Department to redirect personnel and resources away from competing public interest and safety priorities". [2]
  • Justice Department (court filings): Said it "has already disclosed all disclosable information that could conceivably go into an [administrative record]", and that the interview notes "should not be taken as a representative sample". [4]

Sources

  1. Order granting preliminary injunction, ECF 15, 25 Jun 2026
  2. Memorandum Opinion, ECF 16, 25 Jun 2026
  3. Order, ECF 64, 9 Nov 2026
  4. Memorandum Opinion and Order, ECF 65, 9 Nov 2026
  5. Order, ECF 66, 9 Nov 2026

Cite this case

Public Trust Tracker. "Court orders on the Attorney General's compliance with the Epstein Files Transparency Act (Phang v. Blanche)" (PWR-021). Last updated 9 Nov 2026. https://publictrusttracker.org/case/pwr-021-court-orders-on-the-attorney-generals-compliance-with-the/

Suggest a fact check